The debate on asian values started in response to the demands of human rights policy and the quest to flatten cultural differences. He wrote cultural politics and asian values as a postdoctoral fellow in the centre for community and crosscultural studies, queensland university of technology. Like elsewhere in east asia, there certainly was more praise than criticism for. Lee kuan yews singapore bloomed in the shadow of the cold. By his ninth decade, lee kuan yew, prime minister of singapore from 1959 until 1990, had seemingly done it all. Briefly, this article studies the history of lee kuan yews contribution to the asian values debate for three ends. Revisiting the asian values argument used by asian.
In 20, lee published two new books, namely the wit and wisdom of lee kuan yew and one mans view of the world. Vigorous debate over the legacy of singapores first prime minister, lee kuan yew, has continued since his death on march 23, 2015. Lee kuan yew s insights with graham allison and robert blackwill duration. In his interview with foreign affairs marchapril 1994, singapores former prime minister, lee kuan yew, presents interesting ideas about cultural differences between western and east asian societies and the political implications of those differences. Singapore school of the asian values debatepeople such as goh chok tong, lee hsieng loong, kishore mahbubani, tommy koh and bilahari kausikan. Mar 31, 2015 singapaores lee kuan yew thought a competent meritocratic government should not only provide order but also guide economic development. The irresistible shift of global power to the east 2008, chastised the leading western minds of the world for remaining trapped in the past, reluctant or unable to conceive of the possibility that they may have to.
Hence, fay needed tough punishment so that all teenagers, western or asian, would be warned off vandalizing cars in singapore. Witness the outpouring of praise for him upon his death. Human rights and asian values carnegie council for ethics. Dopey drug war recalls asian values debate the manila times. Mahathir and lee kuan yew, of course, are well aware of the political usefulness of asian values, but the type of recent cultural analysis i describe, like the conclusions offered by opinion surveys and questionnaires, demonstrates that these southeast asian leaders do not by any means construct their ideological packages in a cultural vacuum. Few knew what such asian values meant, but lees actions during his political career demonstrated that he was more in favor of western policies and culture. The asian values debate is inseparable from the qualitative and quantitative patterns of development and economic growth in the region.
Lee argued that in a developing country, in order to build fair and strong institutions, the rights of the community must supersede the rights of the individual. Lee kuan yew once championed his ideal as asian values, a unique approach to bringing his country success by finding alternatives to the wests path to freedom and democracy. Lee kuan yew considered east asian culture to be distinct from the western culture. The extraordinary economic growth experienced within east asian countries often achieved under different modalities than that of the neoliberal orthodoxy has put the political and social arrangements of these countries under the spotlight. Discussion on asian values online burmamyanmar library. The eulogies to lee kuan yew, founding father of the modern citystate of singapore, are flooding in for good reason. Lee kuan yew today denies that he has ever spoken of asian values, claiming that he has always advocated confucian values, demonstrating the importance of sinic culture in his thinking and in the asian values debate.
Books by lee kuan yew author of from third world to first. Lee could only speak of the asian values that had transformed singapore from a third world backyard to one of the worlds most propserous nations. Singapores father and the patron of asian values lee kuan yew, the founder of modern singapore, has died at the age of 91. Asian values gained popularity in the peoples republic of china, malaysia under mahathir mohamad, singapore under lee kuan yew, indonesia and in japan perhaps as early as the pre world war ii era. But very roughly speaking, lee kuan yew and kim daejung were debating the relationship between east asian culture and democracy. First, it would be unwise to overlook the ideological resourcefulness of the leading asian values advocates. It is submitted that both lee kuan yew1, a singaporean and aung san suu kyi, a burmese, have made their impact internationally and i further submit that their influence and impact are at least partly due to their ideas though of course, in the case of lee kuan yew his influence is perhaps primarily due to lee. From kaiser wilhelm to lee kuan yew to better understand the character of postdevelopmental asian values in singapore and malaysia, it is helpful to consider briefly historical parallels to imperial germany in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
Lee kuan yew has 29 books on goodreads with 32 ratings. Lee kuan yew is the undisputed architect of the asian values argument. Read online lee kuan yew and the asian values debate book pdf free download link book now. Mar 30, 2015 singapore, in contrast, has become the poster child for the concept of good governance, to quote the financial timess obituary for the countrys longtime leader, lee kuan yew, who was. Few world leaders stood astride as grand a sweep of history as lee or. Ong center for the study of democracy, 3151 social science plaza, university of california, irvine, ca 926975100 abstract the singaporean patriarch lee kuan yew popularized the argument that. Singapore, for example, has been ruled by the peoples action party since independence, and under the leadership of lee kuan yew between 1959 and 1990. The old debate is coming back in a different form courtesy of du30s drug war and the wideranging quarrel over human rights that it has provoked. Positive and normative dimensions phillip wonhyuk lim i. Tony blair pays tribute to lee kuan yew, march 22, 2015.
Although he does not explicitly say so, his statements throughout the interview and his track record make it obvious. This site is like a library, you could find million book here by using search box in the header. The debate over asian values is at the heart of this controversy. Before we get to the quality of his ideas, let us look at the simple and perhaps. Universal human rights, cultural relativism and the asian values debate 9 october 2010. The wit and wisdom of lee kuan yew contains almost 600 quotations which provide a summary of his views on a wide range. Regarding derek davies article how confucius reads the trib 18 january, the law suit against the international herald tribune is not simply over a reference to. In 1977, when he was prime minister of singapore, he launched the term at armslength. Lee kuan yew, the man who remade asia he preached asian values and turned a tiny, poor citystate into an astonishing economic success. Parallels during more than a halfcentury as the citystates leader, lee helped turn the sleepy british colony into an affluent. Universal human rights, cultural relativism and the asian. He was prime minister from 1959 until 1990 and retained considerable influence over the government and economy in the following years, almost up until his death. What lee kuan yew got wrong about asia washington post.
Human rights and asian values carnegie council for. The final verdict will be when the phd students dig out the archives, singapores founding prime minister lee kuan yew told the new york times soberly when asked about his. Lee kuan yew and the myth of asian capitalism the japan times. At the forefront of the socalled asian values debate is dr mahathir mohamad, the prime minister of malaysia, and the former prime minister of singapore, lee kuan yew, along with several other public intellectuals in the region. Lee kuan yew on homosexuality in interview with the sunday times. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it. Many credit lee s 31years at the helm of the country 1959. Singapores midlife crisis as citizens find their voice.
At the forefront of the socalled asian values debate is dr mahathir mohamad, the prime minister of malaysia, and the former prime minister of singapore, lee kuan yew, along with several other. Mar 23, 2015 how lee kuan yew made singapore strong. Center for the study of democracy, 3151 social science plaza, university of california, irvine, ca 926975100. Use the link below to share a fulltext version of this article with your friends and colleagues. One of the key architects of the asian values thesis is the former prime minister of singapore, lee kuan yew, who championed the virtues of social discipline and a paternalistic, illiberal state barr, 2000.
One mans view of the world by respected leader of singapore lee kuan yew presents a sharp and convincing analysis, highlighting the consequences of the inevitable rebalancing of global power between the us and china. The recent death of lee kuan yew, the founding father of singapore, has spawned many articles in the korean media. Create your citations, reference lists and bibliographies automatically using the apa, mla, chicago, or harvard referencing styles. The success of asian capitalism seems to prove him correct. Lee kuan yew was a phenomenon and some leaders may try to emulate his leadership, without achieving the same goal, in the absence of a recipe for success. Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this book to your organisations collection. Scholars such as chua, khoo, langguth and barr note that lee. The issue of implementing universal human rights specifically article 18 of the international covenant on civil and political rights, which articulates the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion continues to be a sensitive and. He did however espouse confucian values and ethics during his time as a ruler.
Lee argued that in a developing country, in order to build fair and strong institutions, the rights of the community must supersede the rights of the. Claims about the benefits of asian values garnered particular attention in the early 1990s, when they were articulated by prominent political figures such as former singaporean prime minister lee kuan yew. Mahathir was a leading proponent of asian values in the 1990s, when he was leader of malaysia. Lee kuan yew 2000 and other proponents of the asian values thesis, for example, have claimed. Lee kuan yew, the former prime minister of singapore and a great champion of asian values, has defended authoritarian arrangements on the ground of their alleged effectiveness in promoting economic success. The irresistible shift of global power to the east 2008, chastised the leading western minds. Did lee kuan yew embody western values or asian values. Alongside singapores lee kuan yew, mahathir strongly argued that individual freedom, in his. The beliefs behind the man, which was based on his dissertation. Reassessing the asian values debate doh chull shin.
The irresistible shift of global power to the east 2008, chastised the. Lee kuan yew, for instance, argues with some bluntness, and some justification, that asian values are not the cause of the meltdown because nepotism, favouritism and corruption have been endemic and present since the asian economic. As a born and raised hong konger with distinct and obvious bloodlines running through a large portion of southern china, i think i can safely say that i am at least somewhat aware of what asian values can be said to be. The singaporean political leader, lee kuan yew, became a strong advocate for this position, arguing that asian societies had different values from western societies and that these values were in important respects superior. For example, lee kuan yew outlines the fundamental difference between western concepts of society and government and east asian concepts by explaining, when i say east asians, i mean korea, japan, china, vietnam, as distinct from southeast asia, which is a mix between the sinic and the indian, though indian culture also emphasizes similar values.
Those who thought that the asian values debate died with lee kuan yew should think again. In this informative book, michael barr, who previously has written a study into lee kuan yew s ideas, revisits the asian values debate, and concludes that the countries of east asia are distinctive, despite the cultural, religious and economic differences which exist within and between these countries. Lee kuan yew and the art of governing asia, opinion news. These statements mattered a hell of a lot to us lgbt activists. Lee kuan yew and the asian values debate barr 2000. If singapore became a westernstyle, democratic society, lee argued. I shall consider this argument before turning to historical issues. The asian value debate came to prominence when it was strongly advocated by the prime minister of singapore, lee kuan yew and also mahathir mohamad. Weve been trying for years to improve singapores laws and social attitudes, against a tide of religious opposition and rhetoric about asian values. Image caption lee kuan yew has retired from the cabinet in may. With asias economy still booming in the second half of the 1990s asian values were announced by some politicians lee kuan yew, mahatir, ishihara, mahbubani etc. Jul 20, 1995 in 1988, the espousal of human rights by this former solicitor general earned him an arrest and 72 days of torture vividly recounted in to catch a tartar.
Lee kuan yew, on how values in asia differed from western values of democracy, freedom of expression and individual rights. Lee s concoction of asian values was meant partly to deter westerners from criticizing repressive regimes. There is an active scholarly debate over whether the hierarchic and deferential social authority relations of confucian traditions are incompatible. In the 1990s, lee, together with his malaysian counterpart, mahathir mohamad, led the global debate, peeling away a blackandwhite western perception of authoritarianism and spelling out in what they called asian values, the many shades between dictatorship and democracy. The singaporean patriarch lee kuan yew popularized the argument that asian values derived from confucian cultural traditions are inconsistent with the development of democracy in east asia. The dangers of culturalist overshooting with asia showing a strong vshaped recovery in 1999, it is perhaps all too easy to dismiss the asian values debate following the asian economic crisis of 1997 as much ado about nothing in retrospect.
In the west, the study of asian values was seen as a way to understand asia and foster a closer relationship with the region. Lee kuan yew s most popular book is from third world to first. A gay mans perspective on lee kuan yew the online citizen. He is particularly renowned as a principle architect of the asian values campaign of the 1990s, which sought to. The asian values debate former singaporean prime minister lee kuan yew popularized the asian values. Singapores brilliant patriarch lee kuan yew became a worldclass pundit, explaining how the unique culture of confucianism permeated asian societies. Mar 24, 2015 with the passing of lee kuan yew, singapores first prime minister and one of the most influential asian politicians, leaders and media outlets all over the world have put in their two cents on. Apr 07, 2015 mr lee kuan yew s most powerful ideas were often counterintuitive, out of the box, controversial, world changing.
873 1449 1351 169 1153 1413 1215 561 798 920 1470 87 1404 278 775 938 1046 202 209 114 1032 1443 298 204 202 55 1258 1017 779 511 603 138 51 655 412 97